Godless Business

Prayer vs Real Work

From http://miscellanea.wellingtongrey.net/2008/12/01/prayer-vs-hard-work/

  • http://SilverClipboard.com/ Wellington Grey

    Thanks for posting my image, but would you mind linking to the page where it came from: http://miscellanea.wellingtongrey.net/2008/12/01/…

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/askegg askegg

      Now that I know where is originated – no problem at all !

  • Matt

    I wouldn't own up to it – it is an unfounded fallcy of the worst order. There is absolutely no evidence that people who pray are less likely to act for others! These are not mutually exclusive. You can pray and act. I would suggest that both are positive ways to respond to the needs of others. In Australia, 80% of charitable organisations are religious and 90% of overall giving is to these organisations. A tiny percentage of charitable organisations are humanist/atheist in motive. Good reason? These views don't motivate people to give.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/askegg askegg

      Who said anything about prayer and it's correlation with action? It's the action that actually helps – prayer just makes you feel good.

      The biggest charity in Australia is the Red Cross – an entirely secular organisation without any religious, political, or national ties.

      I see by your email address you are the reverend at my old school.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/askegg askegg

      Oh – and I posted this in reply David Rietveld's (Wellspring Anglican church in Tasmania) extraordinary claims regarding charity as a result of the Victorian bush fires.

      "It is true that Christian organisations have launched appeals and that this is the right thing to do, however to claim that Christians are the most generous and philanthropic citizens is an extraordinary claim. I wonder if Mr. Rietveld has verifiable data to back up his claim?
      At the I write this article, the organisation that has collect the most funds for the Victorian bushfire victims is the Red Cross, who managed to collect over $50 million dollars in less than 4 days. Current estimates place the total donations are around $100 million dollars – all to an organisation which “makes no discrimination as to nationality, race, religious beliefs, class or political opinions.”.
      This is in stark contrast to St. Vincent De Paul which “is a lay Catholic organisation that aspires to live the gospel message by serving Christ“, and The Salvation Army whose “message is based on the Bible. Its ministry is motivated by love for God. Its mission is to preach the gospel of Jesus Christ“.
      Of course, it may be argued that it is primarily Christians that give to all of these organisations (the Red Cross included), but again without hard evidence to back this up it is difficult to tell."

      The original post is here: http://godless.biz/2009/02/15/wellspring-of-falla…

  • azenis

    Which has what, exactly, to do with the image?

    If a charity is religious by nature or origin, I won't give to it. Period. Love the reaction when Salvos etc ring up after my money and I say "Sorry I don't support religious organisations". They do not know how to react ;)

  • azenis

    And Matt I think you have missed the point of the diagram. It is simply saying that prayer alone will do nothing. But, we all know, in the real world, you don't get something from nothing, do we…. A single pair of hands working will achieve infinitely more than a million hands clasped in prayer.

  • Kevin

    I just wanted to post to say that I completely disagree. Prayer is the starting point off of which any action I take comes from. It's the only way to make sure that what I'm doing is what God's will is. And that is the #1 priority. Not mine, but his. Prayer allows for the opportunity for action to be taken, but misguided action (those without prayer) can cause more harm than good.

    • azenis

      So you have no will of your own, and if you do, you don't trust it. But in reality you do, of course you have your own will, you just credit it to an imaginary friend. I guess that relieves you from any responsibility for poor choices. "God works in mysterious ways", "Its all part of gods plan" and whatever other excuse for poor decision making you care to make….

    • Cometa

      I would tend to agree with Kevin, but I think what you are calling prayer, I would call thinking. I would think before taking actions; if you don't think about it and research it, you can do some serious harm.

      I see the image as meaning that prayer alone does nothing. Actions make the difference, not the prayer.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/askegg askegg

      You can start by praying if you like, but it's the action that has an effect. Prayer alone has none. It does not work. God is either not listening to people's prayer, or he doesn't care, or he doesn't exist.

  • azenis

    Is prayer not asking your god who is supposed to love all his "children" equally to do favours and give special treatment?

Subscribe to the Podcast

44 – An Atheist Temple

BBC News – Row over Indonesia atheist Facebook post Priority is to protect marriage | Herald Sun No Fetus Can Feed Us | Unreasonable Faith Alain de Botton: Atheism 2.0 | Video on TED.com

Standard Podcast [ 1:44:50 ] Play Now | Download

Further Reading

Dog Heads

The excellent British broadcaster BBC 4 recently aired a fascinating program called “The Medieval Mind” which explores the philosophy, theology, and predominate thinking of the dark ages.  The first episode deals with knowledge and revealed numerous intriguing insights into how the medieval mind determined epistemological truths. Monks, priests, and other godly people were in possession…
Read more …

Matt’s Human Morality

Matt Dillhunty (president of the Atheist Community of Austin, co-host of “Non-Prophets Radio“, and “The Atheist Experience”) recently debated Father Hans Jacobse (an Antiochian Orthodox Priest) at The University of Maryland on 16th November.  Full video of the event can be found here (although only 6 of the 9 videos have been posted online as…
Read more …

Aunt Matilda’s Cake

In the book “God’s Undertaker: Has Science Buried God?” by John Lennox he puts forward the example of Aunt Matilda’s cake to illustrate the limited nature of science. The scenario has Aunt Matilda baking a cake and number of scientists are asked to describe it. A nutritionists might tell us about the carbohydrates, fats, sugars,…
Read more …

Atheism 2.0

“Atheism 2.0” is a 20 minute TED presentation by Alain de Botton in which he proposes a new approach to evangelising atheism. Alain suggests (apparently without evidence) that we have “secularised badly” and we should sift through the rituals, traditions, and behaviours of religion to identify and adopt their efficient mechanisms. “I have come here…
Read more …

The Bizarre Bible

Atheists are often told by believers to read the Bible and it will all become clear.  Trouble is, many of us have tried that and it doesn’t seem to have helped.  Take these verses for example: This does not sound like a great night out to me. “But Rabshakeh said unto them, Hath my master…
Read more …

Vaccinations save lives!

Measles is a highly contagious viral infection of the respiratory system, whose symptoms include fever, cough, runny nose, red eyes and a generalised skin rash. Typically the incubation period (from initial infection to the onset of symptoms) is around 4 days, after which the disease lasts approximately another 4 days. The patient will usually cough,…
Read more …