The threat survives

In September of 2001 the civilised world awoke to the grim reality that terror could stretch its black clawed hand across the globe into the heart of America.  As the events of the 9/11 beamed across the world we all fixed our eyes to the horror and wondered about our own sense of security.  Here in plain view the fanatics, driven by political ideology and back with religious fervour, executed their retaliation for unknown crimes.  There have been defining moments in history which change the world forever, and everyone instinctively knew the fall of the two towers was one such pivotal moment.

The President of the United States declared war on the phantom of “terror” and began stripping away civil liberties for the sake of security.  The Department of Homeland Security was formed,  airports banned liquids, searched bags, and introduced invasive back scatter x-rays to weed out those bent on destruction.  But most importantly, a single man was identified as the sole cause of all this death and fear.  Osama Bin Laden.

While we may never really know the true motivations behind Osama Bin Laden’s actions, it seems he may not have been able to convince many young intelligent men sacrifice themselves and hundreds of passengers without the religious ideas of jihad, martyrdom, and eternal paradise.  While it’s not impossible for people to be convinced to sacrifice their lives for political reasons, the path is much smoother if 72 virgins await beyond the pearly gates.

Now one head of this vicious hydra has been severed a chapter of the 9/11 book can be closed, but the story continues.  The real threat are the dogmas of superstition which so easily permit such atrocities; and this is something almost all faiths must share a burden.  History shows the wooly thinking which allows the wishes of judgemental gods to intrude on decent society bears the seeds of destruction, violence, intolerance, and bigotry.

Until we are willing to face this stark reality, I fear the spectre of terror will continue to dominate our culture.

Tagged with: , ,


  • Richard Leslie Whereat

    Well of course. But we'll allow this hydra to exist, because "we must respect religion".

    • http://thinkingdoesnthurt.blogspot.com/ David_Gibson

      I don't think it is in practicality a case of 'allowing the hydra to exist' – some people will believe what they wish regardless of whether it is popular or acceptable to an authority.

      I see no reason to think that one day no one will be a religious extremist let alone any other ideological extremist. Powerful entities in any sociopolitical context (be it a local council to the international stage) always collect and acquire enemies and opposition. The bigger the stage the greater the propensity for extremism, regardless of whether religious (or "wooly") thinking actually does provide a smoother path to extreme views (a difficult causation-correlation problem).

      Perpetual vigilance is the price to pay for prosperity and power. However, I can't help but note the USA's foreign policy over the last 60 years has played a significant role in fermenting the hatred groups like Al Qaeda have for the USA.

  • http://thingsfindothinks.com AndrewFinden

    While it’s not impossible for people to be convinced to sacrifice their lives for political reasons, the path is much smoother if 72 virgins await beyond the pearly gates.

    I know that Islam promises this to matyrs, but I wonder just how many of these suicide bombers were not actually motivated by anger and resentment to what they saw as oppression to Islam and their culture etc? (not at all saying it was justified, just questioning whether the motivation was for simply for heavenly reward or not). I think David makes some very good points – much of this is the fall-out from bad foreign policy, and attempts to point the finger solely at religion as the 'root of all evil' is, I think, simplistic (though it makes for great rhetoric and sells lots of books!). When people do these things without religion as well it only goes to show that the problem is much deeper and people will recruit and distort whatever they need to achieve their ends, be it politics, religion, ethnicity and even (psuedo) science.

    It is interesting to see the way the 'war on terrorism' has been used to justify the restrictions on civil liberties. One can't help but see glimpses of the way the National Socialists (amongst other dictatorships) used similar 'emergency' laws to take control. While I don't think that 9/11 was a US government conspiracy the way the Reichstag fire probably was, I can at least see where some might get the idea from!

    On the point of airport security, you might find this interesting: http://www.thestar.com/printarticle/744199


Father Bob and Aronra

This week I meet with Aronra in Melbourne for the Global Atheist Convention, and thought it would be a good idea to chat up with Australia’s most popular secular humanist Catholic Father Bob for a chat.  Strap yourself in for this one.


Further Reading

Excellent Marriage

On Thursday the 17th May the churches of Tasmania will be hosting an event at the Stanley Burbury Theatre entitled “Excellent Marriage”.  According to their web site the event “aims to celebrate the importance and value of marriage for the Australian community”.  They say  “people from religious and non-religious backgrounds, young and old, are all invited to…
Continue reading

More Ultimate Answers

This is a continuation of my reply to Andrew Finden’s “one last philosophical hurrah” post, and addresses the question “why believe there is a god?” It is encouraging to read the opening statement of this section where Andrew admits “that one can cannot prove that God exists”, however he quickly (and rightly) dismisses philosophical materialism…
Continue reading

Ultimate Answers

Those who have been following this blog for a while will, no doubt, recall the various discussions/debates/arguments I have had with Andrew Finden in the past. As frustrating as I find them at times, I think he often tackles interesting and difficult topics with a calm intelligence not very often found in the religious debate. This…
Continue reading

Dear Mr. Swan,

Wayne Swan is currently having meeting to finalise the Australian federal budget.  In these tough economic times it is more important than ever to ensure your hard earned tax dollar is being spent in the most effective and efficient manner.  In view of this I can think of one poorly thought out federal program which,…
Continue reading

We have it all

Last weekend I attend the second Global Atheist Convention run by the Atheist Foundation of Australia in Melbourne. The convention attracted over 4,000 attendees to listen to extraordinary line up of world class speakers from a variety of disciplines on a wide range of topics. The convention began with a comedy line up including the brilliantly hilarious…
Continue reading

Poor Pell

Last Monday on Australia’s ABC television network the jet-lagged evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins squared off against Catholic Cardinal George Pell on the “Q and A” program with unimpressive results. A transcript of the entire show can be found in the ABC’s web site. The level of intellectual debate on this episode of Q and A…
Continue reading


Back to top

Follow @askegg, @cynskeptical, @jimpalfreyman, and @nigelhoney on Twitter.

Designed by Andrew Skegg for using the Twitter Bootstrap framework.